Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Commentary: Rihanna, Chris Brown ‘Cake’ collab ‘middle finger’ to fans

spates.3@osu.edu

Published: Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Updated: Tuesday, February 21, 2012 20:02

Rihanna

Courtesy of MCT, Photo illustration by Brittany Schock / Asst. photo editor

Chris Brown (bottom) featured on a remix of Rihanna’s (top) ‘Birthday Cake,’ released Feb. 20.

"Brown resumed punching Robyn F. and she interlocked her fingers behind her head and brought her elbows forward to protect her face. She then bent over at the waist, placing her elbows and face near her lap in [an] attempt to protect her face and head from the barrage of punches being levied upon her by Brown."

This is from the police report that was released after R&B artist Chris Brown beat up his then-girlfriend, pop sensation Rihanna, born Robyn Fenty. For a woman who was beaten so badly, you'd think she'd have learned at least one thing: self-respect.

Apparently that has all gone out the window when a chance to snatch another No. 1 single from her latest album, "Talk That Talk," came along. After a week and a half of rumors, Rihanna and her former beau tweeted the download links to remixes of "Turn Up The Music" and "Birthday Cake." Not only is this desperation at its finest, it's repulsive.

I guess Rihanna forgot that Brown "punched her in the left eye with his right hand … continued to punch her in the face with his right hand … The assault caused Robyn F.'s mouth to fill with blood and blood to splatter all over her clothing and the interior of the vehicle." I guess Rihanna forgot how she spoke out against going back to your abuser to millions of people. I guess Rihanna doesn't care that thousands of her fans on Twitter are unfollowing her and tweeting pictures of them burning and breaking her albums in protest to this collaboration.

In the words of Rihanna herself: "Chiefin' while ppl spend hrs on letters... *kanye shrug* #phuckit." Why should we care if she doesn't?

I'll tell you why: There are millions of abuse victims that actually looked up to Miss Fenty and held her up as a beacon of strength and hope in the face of adversity and hateful violence. Despite her mostly trashy lyrics and illiterate manner of tweeting, Rihanna was, for a brief time, a symbol to many women.

But because she's young, rebellious and self-centered, she threw away the chance to be something more than a sexual singer for a cheap publicity stunt and possible reconciliation with a man who nearly beat her to death and threatened to kill her.

I, myself, have said that the celebrity role model died when Britney Spears buzzed her head and that parents shouldn't be looking to celebrities to raise their kids. However, this is a different situation. No one is asking Rihanna to be a role model — we're just asking for a little self-respect. Collaborating with your abuser isn't showing forgiveness, it's showing that you're weak and have no tact.

And for anyone who says I've never been in Rihanna's shoes so how could I know what she's going through, I won't go into my own past in detail, but yes I have and I'm still not over it, so how could she be? Maybe this was a big f--- you to the media and all her haters, but in reality, that middle finger was felt most by her fans and former fans like myself, who will never look at her the same.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Anonymous
Fri Feb 24 2012 12:55
@ Annie - other comments on here disagree with the author's point of view and they're still here. Also, do you really think journalism students would be given that sort of control on the website? Come on. My guess is you hit the wrong button accidentally. Cheers!
Annie
Fri Feb 24 2012 00:26
I left a comment last night and I'm pretty sure it went through...did The Lantern/author delete it because I challenged the author's views? Anything worth being read is worth being argued over and if you can't handle a faceless comment from a reader on your opinion piece then perhaps consider another extracurricular.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 23 2012 10:58
There's a difference between caring for abuse victims and drudging up Rihanna's three-year-old case. One she obviously doesn't care much about, a that. People need to learn to let these things die. Who cares about Brown? If you want to demonize something so badly, demonize abuse in general--and not the abusive person. Those people get what's coming to them, regardless of what, exactly, those people had come to them. We should instead be helping the victims.

Also: others should stop judging so readily. A lot of people are saying Brown deserves more punishment; how many folk of that ilk would actually condemn their own child for those actions? Few, I wager.

This media machine makes it all a very sad situation.

JJ
Wed Feb 22 2012 18:03
I don't think it is an f-you to fans, I think it is an f-you to critics. Hitting another person is wrong, I was once a victim of abuse by both a boyfriend and my father. But to sit here and judge her forgiving him is wrong too. She is allowed to forgive, and even have a friendship if she likes. I was abused and I never looked up to her as a role model, so don't say she was a symbol of strength for people like me, she wasn't, and based on her "trashy" music, I don't know what respectable person would look up to her. I am not a fan of either of them but to sit back and judge their relationship or their forgiveness is wrong. We don't know the whole story, it isn't our business, if you don't like the music, don't buy it or listen to it, but don't sit there and act like you are better or act like they should have done something differently just because they are in the spotlight or act like you would have done something differently. Don't judge something until you have experienced it.
Anonymous
Wed Feb 22 2012 15:07
I can't believe that I find myself agreeing with Mr. Kanye West -- but I do.
Ali
Wed Feb 22 2012 11:03
I completely agree with you. I wish she would understand that she's a role model whether she wants to be or not and this sends out a terrible message to everyone that looks up to her. This stunt just doesn't make sense to me. It's done nothing to gain fans, and only alienated the ones she had.
mel
Wed Feb 22 2012 10:13
I think it is despicable as well. I can understand forgiving, but I would never forget, and I would certainly keep my distance. I have never been in her shoes, true, but this is just sad.






log out