Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Legal drinking age debated: 18 or 21?

clements.78@osu.edu

Published: Sunday, November 8, 2009

Updated: Monday, November 9, 2009 21:11

When someone turns 18, they're allowed to enlist in the armed forces, be summoned for jury duty, get married and even adopt a child. Drinking a beer, however, remains illegal.

This commonly argued law was thrown into the spotlight Monday night during the Ohio Union Activities Board's "Let's See Some ID: The Drinking Age Debate."

In front of a student crowd in Independence Hall, two national experts represented a different side of the spectrum and presented their arguments.

William DeJong, professor at Boston University, argued in favor of keeping the legal drinking age at 21. DeJong is a former director of the U.S. Dept. of Higher Education Center for Alcohol and Other Drug Prevention.

Barrett Seaman, who has spent 30 years as a correspondent and editor for Time Magazine, argued to lower the drinking age. Earlier in the decade, Seaman spent two and a half years at 12 colleges and universities studying the social lives of college students.

Both men were given a 10-minute opening statement, then fielded questions from the audience,

DeJong primarily presented statistics, stating that alcohol-related car crashes are much more common for adults older than 21.

"The fact is, this 21-and-over law has saved lives," he said. "If we lower the drinking age to 18, a lot of the problems we're having now will simply transfer down to the high school level."

Seaman argued that even though the 21-and-over law may have saved people from drunk driving deaths, even more deaths are occurring away from the road as binge drinking has become more prevalent. "I have a lot of respect for statistics, but I don't necessarily rely on them," he said. "Pre-gaming is why more and more people are getting carted off to the hospital these days."

While both experts differed in opinion, both agreed that more emphasis be put upon drinking during college.

"Little by little I think we're educating people," Seaman said.  

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

3 comments

Anonymous
Tue Mar 9 2010 13:01
Very true, drinkning and driving will take your life
millertime
Wed Nov 11 2009 17:12
Lower the drinking age to 18. If you're old enough to go to war, you're old enough to go to the bar. 'Nuff said.

I agree. I also would not be opposed to making the legal adult age and drinking age 19 so that most of the people are not in high school when they are allowed to start drinking.

Ajax the Great
Tue Nov 10 2009 17:20
"DeJong primarily presented statistics, stating that alcohol-related car crashes are much more common for adults older than 21."

So why are we allowing adults over 21 to drink, and denying this right to those who are LESS likely to drink and drive (18-20 year olds)? Isn't that just a little unfair? Lets's face it, statistics show that 21-24 year olds have always been worse than 18-20 year olds as far as drunk driving deaths goes, even when the drinking age was 18. Why? People over 21 are more likely to have cars and less likely to have parental supervison than 18 year olds, and our society (the same one that has zero tolerance when it comes people under 21) just nods and winks at their drunken antics no matter how stupid. And there is little doubt that raising the drinking age merely shifted some deaths into the future by a few years, with no net lifesaving effect.

"If we lower the drinking age to 18, a lot of the problems we’re having now will simply transfer down to the high school level."

Or, rather, raising the drinking age to 21 dumped those same problems onto college presidents, who are less equipped to deal with that than parents. Many of the latter apparently being too afraid to do anything but stick their heads in the sand, so they want it to stay 21. And there's a big difference between high school and college in that the situation is more contained in the former. Besides, even 8th graders currently find alcohol easier to get than cigarettes according to surveys, as do 10th graders. Thus, I doubt things will get significantly worse for high schoolers if the drinking age was lowered to 18. So relax already!

Lower the drinking age to 18. If you're old enough to go to war, you're old enough to go to the bar. 'Nuff said.







log out