Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Ohio State student bitten by shark, asked to keep quiet

fairchild.84@osu.edu

Published: Thursday, March 21, 2013

Updated: Friday, March 22, 2013 02:03

Monika Wanis

Courtesy of Monika Wanis

Monika Wanis, a 4th-year in anthropology and psychology, sits on a rocky beach in Belize. She was bitten by a shark while snorkeling off the coast.


One Ohio State student’s visit to Belize over spring break ended with a shark bite, but she said some people are trying to get her to stay quiet.

Monika Wanis, a fourth-year in anthropology and psychology, said a shark bit her on her toe during a trip to Belize with Buck-I-Serv to give out shoes with an organization called One World Running. She’s recovering from the incident, but she said she believes officials from Buck-I-Serv are more concerned with protecting their name and reputation than they are about her well-being.

“In the email that they sent me, basically the first sentence said, ‘How are you feeling, I hope you got medical care,’ and then the remainder of the email said, ‘I hope you consider posting positive things on Facebook about One World Running and Buck-I-Serv because they do not want bad publicity and press.’ I didn’t put anything negative about Buck-I-Serv or One World Running on Facebook because it’s not their fault,” Wanis said. “I just want people to realize that they’re not out to make sure that I’m safe, they’re out to make sure that their name doesn’t get a bad rep.”

The bite took place on a snorkeling excursion.

Wanis had geared up and boarded one of the two boats taking the group out for snorkeling on an island called Caye Caulker. The group was heading out to a part of the Caribbean Sea with stingrays and nurse sharks.

Prior to getting into the water, Wanis said the instructors threw buckets of fish into the water because nurse sharks eat shrimp and fish. Wanis and another one of her classmates then asked the instructor if anyone had ever been injured on this type of snorkeling excursion before and he assured them that they had not.

After Wanis had been in the water for about two minutes, she said she asked the instructor if she could touch any of the sharks or stingrays.

“He said, ‘Yeah absolutely, they don’t harm you,’ and then went to go get me a stingray,” Wanis said. “When he was lifting up the stingray, I felt the shark bite me.”

Wanis immediately swam to the instructor and said she had been bitten; she said he then pushed her toward the boat yelling to her to get out of the water. Another instructor lifted her up to the boat and they immediately headed back to shore. The shark had bitten a toe on her right foot.

One of Wanis’ advisers on the trip wrapped her toe in a towel to prevent more bleeding.

However, there was still one problem when they got back to land.

“When we got back to shore there was a guy there that said there was no nurse, and then the instructor told me there was no hospital or doctors on the island,” Wanis said.

One of the advisers on the trip ran to get another adviser who had been a nurse for 30 years from One World Running, who was also on a mission trip there, while Wanis stayed back on the boat with the instructor. To distract herself from the pain, Wanis said she tried to strike up a conversation. During this conversation she found out the instructor had also been bitten by one of the sharks as he spread apart his toes to show her the scar.

Wanis’ adviser returned to the boat and carried her into a golf cart that they rode to the nurse’s clinic.

“The clinic was just a room with nothing in it but like a little bed,” Wanis said.

Once in the clinic, Wanis said everyone was trying to convince her that she had only stepped on a shell. Wanis argued that it could not have been, and that the instructor had been bitten by one of the sharks as well.

Wanis said that at the time of the incident she could feel her leg being jerked back.

Wanis said she was not able to get stitches at the clinic.

“They just squeezed the blood out, cleaned it with saline solution and they used Dermabond on it. They glued it together and wrapped it up still bleeding,” Wanis said. “They gave me ibuprofen 800 and amoxicillin and I ended up taking ibuprofen 800 every five to six hours because the pain was really, really bad.”

Wanis returned to the beach and waited for the other students to come back from the snorkeling trip. When they returned, Wanis said one student told her that the instructor said he had seen the shark bite her.

“One of the girls said, ‘No after you left the snorkeling instructor said that he told everyone it was a shell as soon as it happened because he didn’t want everyone to panic and try to get in one boat.’ Then when everyone got in both boats he told them it was indeed a shark,” Wanis said.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

36 comments

Anonymous
Wed May 8 2013 20:14
And lastly, the fact that they used some kind of glue-bonding material on her foot shows some sort of modernism. Because doctors here in the US use that stuff all the time to minimalize scarring and also if stiches cannot be done, then they use the bonding glue for that.
Anonymous
Wed May 8 2013 20:07
NOt for nothing, but Im a little concerned about this article in general. Because if the shark had truly bitten her then why did it only bite her toe? Could it be that it may have been one of the fishes? I have been nipped by those little suckers before and it can be painful. The nurse sharks are very friendly and sweet. Im not trying to downplay this incident. Im just curious as to the extent of the injury. With regards to medical care in Belize, I can tell you that there really isn't much medical care. For one to blame the excursion for this travesty is obsurd. Trained professionals can still get bit. When you swim with these kinds of animals, you take the self imposed risk of getting bit. I swim with the sharks every time I am in Belize which is every year and luckily have never had an incident. However, a giant barracuda swam right by me which freaked me out more, as those will do some nasty damage to you. If this company is a do good type of company, then I wouldnt go so far as to trash it however, they should ensure your safety just keep in mind the risks that are taken when travelling to 3rd world countries. It's just like if a person gets bit by a Fer De Lance snake in the jungle. The closest hospital to the jungle is in Belize City and the ride from the jungle to to the city can take about 2/3 hours and is a rough ride at that and in the interim a person can either die or sustain extraordinary tissue damage. TO the victim, im sorry you had to endure such a horrible experience and I hope you recover well. Dont give up on helping others because of this incident.
OSUstudent
Thu Apr 18 2013 00:41
Are you people retarded? Ohio State put the entire group on an island with no hospital, no doctors, no nurses. End of story. And we're blaming a girl for getting hurt? "Bad PR for OSU"? Are you done? So what, any serious cuts and you just bleed out and die and it's your own fault? All this 'fend for yourself' nonsense is exhausting.
Anonymous
Fri Apr 5 2013 09:16
Doesn't surprise me, I've heard a lot of shady things about Buck-I-Serv. Definitely wouldn't trust them to go out of the country, excursion or not.
Anonymous
Wed Apr 3 2013 01:16
not surprised that this happenned. But the students were probably under the impression that the excursion guides wouldnt put them in any danger.But they did! They let them in the water with sharks and sting rays.at feeding time. And I can't believe that there werent any doctors or a hospital. What kind of responsible organization takes their volunteers to a place with no doctor or hospital for emergency situations??????????Who ever is in charge of these Organizations needs to be fired.Just because someone is running a tour doesnt mean that they are qualified or certified or even properly trained. These are just ordinary people trying to make a buck. hopefully Ohio State will make some rules about only sending their students to places where there are doctors. I hope she gets some justice.
Anonymous
Tue Mar 26 2013 21:21
It's sad to see so many people commenting on the fact that she's crying because of a "scratch on her toe" and that she is seeking pity. I don't think that's what she's doing at all. I think we should leave the extent of the injury and how painful it was to the individual, not to our own assumptions because we weren't there. Monika is in my class and she's on a lot of medication and I personally saw her toe and it's pretty gross, it still bleeds through a couple layers of gauze and her accident was almost two weeks ago. She also doesn't look too comfortable on crutches and in one of those big black boots. I wonder what benefit it provides for people by posting hurtful comments that have no basis?
Anonymous
Mon Mar 25 2013 22:49
Buck-I-SERV is an organization for volunteering. If Monika can honestly work with people less fortunate than herself for a week, and then come back to the trip only to talk about her toe (that she can live without) rather than the people she helped, then she clearly is not a participant Buck-I-SERV wants to have in the future. This entire article is an embarrassment, great job trying to put community service in a bad light. Luckily, Buck-I-SERV will continue because one person's "bad" experience will not alter the minds of any sensible human being.
Anonymous
Mon Mar 25 2013 15:12
This article is really bad PR for Ohio State. Apparently four years of schooling there buys zero common sense. This moron got into chummed water with sharks and is crying over a scratch on her toe. And her idiot friend is quoted as attributing the bite to a "nursing shark". Hahahahahaha. People like these should not be permitted to leave the country, they give Americans a bad name. She sounds really genuinely charitable too. Tarnishing the name of a non-profit over an accident that she caused on a private excursion, separate from the company. Get a life you sad, pathetic person.
Anonymous
Mon Mar 25 2013 12:19
The ocean is not a petting zoo. If these so called "instructors" would stop feeding and harassing the sharks and rays accidents like this would not happen. I imagine a toe looks a lot like a piece of fish to a shark. This probably happens a lot more than reported.
Anonymous
Sat Mar 23 2013 18:24
I'm a Caye Caulker native as well and I too have been bitten by a Nurse Shark! I got bitten on my fingertip and I only made a single at the moment I was bitten! I left it to bleed for a little before even taking care of it. Stop crying like a baby! You're blowing this thing WAY out of proportion!! I believe all you want is to get attention and to slander other people! Not a chance in hell would you EVER have to go to any such doctor for a small bite like that!! Plus, it's your own stupidity and carelessness that led to that bite!! If you had been watching the sharks to ensure that none were near your feet, it would not have happened!! I am a sideman for one of the local tour companies and I ALMOST ALWAYS tell our guests to watch their feet while the rest know that by sheer common sense, but it seems that common sense isn't too common anymore! I was bitten because I was stupidly trying to feed it and I admit that, but you don't see me making any noise about it!!! Also, you're very contradictory in what you said because first you said that there was no nurse or doctor or any medical facility on the island, then you said there were!! Let me tell ALL OF YOU who read this, we have a nurse and we have a doctor and a clinic! If the doctor OR nurse feel that there is no need for stitches, then there is NO NEED FOR STITCHES!!!! And also, the guide wasn't lying just caz he wanted to, he was lying so as to not create panic among everyone! That was a smart and professional move to do! I have nothing more to say except to stop being a wimp and a big baby and stop trying to get into the spotlight!!!!!
Anonymous
Sat Mar 23 2013 16:20
I am a native of Caye Caulker, and here, we love our sharks and sting rays. For us, this type of thing is a minor issue that's worth mentioning because battle scars are worth bragging rights at the bar. This incident ranks up there along with getting gaffed with a fish hook or some such thing. It's not food for a pity party. Woman up, girl. How many people do you know who have swum with sharks and stingrays? Grab a pint and get bragging. The glass if half full, not half empty. Think of the wonderful stories you'll be able to tell your kids and grandkids.
Anonymous
Sat Mar 23 2013 16:17
I am a native of Caye Caulker, and here, we love our sharks and sting rays. For us, this type of thing is a minor issue that's worth mentioning because battle scars are worth bragging rights at the bar. This incident ranks up there along with getting gaffed with a fish hook or some such thing. It's not food for a pity party. Woman up, girl. How many people do you know who have swum with sharks and stingrays? Grab a pint and get bragging. The glass if half full, not half empty.
Anonymous
Sat Mar 23 2013 13:48
If she still has a toe it clearly wasn't that serious of an injury. Toes are rather easy to bite off by any animal with teeth so if you actually did get bitten by the shark it must have barely touched you. As an ER resident I know that if someone comes in with a dog bite (which are probably far more severe than what happened to you) we will do the exact same thing that this nurse did (we would have use an antiseptic instead of saline, but saline is a quite efficient cleaner as well). Dermabond has been shown to be as effective as stitches and will often be used on feet where people don't care if they get a scar. It sickens me that people are suggesting you get a lawyer. This article reflects much more poorly on the Lantern and the OSU community as a whole than on a service organization that had nothing to do with your injury and was just trying to stop you from scaring potential future members.
Anonymous
Fri Mar 22 2013 23:00
Love the detail and the writing style
Anonymous
Fri Mar 22 2013 23:00
Love the detail and the writing style.
Anonymous
Fri Mar 22 2013 21:38
Monika told me that today after seeing an orthopedic doctor that her nerve is permanently damaged. She's on 4 meds for at least three months, in a boot and on crutches. It's serious she doesn't have sensation in her toe which is permanent!! Her doctor told her that if proper medical care was taken such as getting stitches, all of this could have been avoided. And Monika isn't mad that she got bit, she's upset that buck I serv is trying to get her to lie and say it's a shell and say that she did get proper care, which clearly she didn't. She also didn't say anything negative about buck I serv, she specifically said it wasn't their fault, she's just upset that they are trying to cover it up and that their primary concern is their reputation although they claim its student safety.
Kevin Cole
Fri Mar 22 2013 20:09
Oh no, a woman talking about a bad experience with an organization! Let's get her! ... But seriously, I know Monika on a personal level, I went to high school with her as well as attend the same university, anybody who says she is doing this for attention obviously doesn't know her. She is always participating in activities and is actively social, she wouldn't blow something out of proportion just to get attention and (thank you Dan for pointing this out) she never blamed the group either. She simply explained what had happened and how she probably won't be attending any more trips with the group. So seriously people, calm down.
Anonymous
Fri Mar 22 2013 19:05
I know Monika personally. She loves attention as the story clearly shows. It's a toe! Her mental health is fine. Just stop giving her attention, Obviously she will do anything, even tarnishing a good non-profit, to get it. Disgraceful that this article was even written.
Anonymous
Fri Mar 22 2013 19:01
I smell book offers and movie deals in your near future Monika. That story is spellbinding! What is a shell?.....what is a shark? I just can't get enough!
Trying to be Christian
Fri Mar 22 2013 17:25
The Lord Christ teaches us:  "Judge not, and you shall not be judged. Condemn not, and you shall not be condemn" (Luke 6:37). Whether Monika is or is not blowing this out of proportion, do not condemn her. As for the flaws in the handling of the situation by Buck-I-Serv, there is no reason to overly condemn them either but rather each of the parties should acknowledge the other first and seek the other's interests: "Let each of you look out not only for his own interests, but also for the interests of others" (Phil. 2:4). God bless.




log out