Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Some Ohio State students oppose Boy Scouts gay ban

kim.3712@osu.edu

Published: Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Updated: Thursday, February 28, 2013 00:02

boy scouts

Courtesy of MCT

Protesters gather outside the Boy Scouts of America national headquarters in Irving, Texas, Feb. 6 to voice their opposition against allowing gays as members.

Some Ohio State students want the Boy Scouts of America to end its ban on openly gay members.

The ban currently excludes gay Scout membership and adult leaders in the Boy Scouts of America, but the policy is set to be reconsidered in May.

The organization originally announced that it would reconsider the policy in February, but postponed the decision until May “after careful consideration and extensive dialogue,” according to a statement. The delay was announced on Feb. 6.

Boy Scouts of America reports that about 70 percent of its groups are backed by religious organizations. But many LGBT activist groups have taken offense to the policy. In early February, a petition with an estimated 1.4 million signatures opposing the current ban was delivered to the Boy Scouts of America national headquarters in Irving, Texas, according to multiple reports.

Caroline Ott, a fourth-year in English, said she thinks the policy should be changed.

“I identify as a Catholic but I don’t think there is anything wrong with this proposal. Individuals have the passion to work with these kids and change their lives, so it shouldn’t matter how … they identify themselves,” Ott said. “You can’t consider it to be a black and white situation.”

Zacchary Stottsberry, a first-year in linguistics and Italian, agreed.

“A lot of religious groups even accept gay members of the community in their church groups. For them, it’s not like it’s a big factor,” Stottsberry said. “It shouldn’t hold people back from doing something they want to do because of their sexual orientation … I don’t think it’s right. It’s not ethical I guess.”

Even though people must wait until May to know whether the membership standards proposal passes, some students are expecting the Boy Scouts of America to change its stance.

“With the recent changes that have been happening with the LGBT community, I don’t see how (it) is not going to happen,” Stottsberry said.

Kayla Higginbotham, a first-year in psychology and LGBT rights activist, said she is confident the proposal is going to pass and will lead America in the right direction.

“Eventually, our country, I don’t know how long it would take, but it will move toward progression with accepting homosexuals in every different way,” Higginbotham said. “I think through this process that’s happening right now, we will be able to be more open to homosexuality.”

Jen Koma, spokeswoman for the Boy Scouts’ Simon Kenton Council, which serves central and southern Ohio and northern Kentucky, said in an email that the organization is declining any interviews about the policy change issue since no decision has been made.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

4 comments

Anonymous
Sun Mar 24 2013 18:09
This discussion is far from how the comments portray it. There are many Scouts and Scouters who do not approve of the policy.

There are man who believe that discrimination is not "morally straight." I am one of them. I am an Eagle Scout. I disagree with the policy. It should be changed. Your characterization of this debate as a battle between the Scouts and outsiders is not accurate. There are many of us, who strongly believe that tolerance is an important American value. We believe that the policy weakens The Scouts' moral standing in this society.

This policy is about whether people who want to support the mission of Scouting, and American values, should be prevented from doing so merely because they happen to be gay. This Eagle's answer to that question is a resounding no.

Anonymous
Sat Mar 2 2013 21:43
This all comes down to the support needs from outside entities and the Scouts being pushed into a decision by a twisted set of ideals in this country, invented by lobbyist of special interest groups. People have twisted the rights around so much that many folks don't know which end is up anymore. Why should my agenda be forced down anyone's throat to the extent that the law would protect me? This could go on forever and ever. I think I should be able to impress my agenda on everyone..............can I make that into law also if I get enough lobbyists on my side and spend enough money for commercials? What a mess we have made of our wonderful country!
Anonymous
Fri Mar 1 2013 10:19
Glad to see that humanities students are living in "reality". They can ponder once more why the BSA still has the ban four years from now while they are waiting tables. The truth is that the measure is not going to pass and the ban will stay. There is even a measure being considered to never bring up the issue again and also a proposal by some Pro-traditionists that the BSA board members who keep proposing this divisve issue be kicked off the board. The Pro-traditionalists are "sharpening their swords" for battle come May. The putting off of the vote has given the Pro-Traditionalists time to marshall their forces. The Pro BSA side won't go down without a fight. Remember the Chik-Fil-A backlash? BSA has been around over 103 years, it will not and should not cave to a vocal minority. There are many wealthy donors ready to back-up the BSA should it lose it's funding by prominent businesses.
Anonymous
Thu Feb 28 2013 13:00
When it comes to this issue, the BSA is damned if they do, and damned if they don't. If they'd been open & inclusive towards not only gays but also agnostics and atheists from the beginning, then they could have avoided this whole mess. But they made their bed, now they gotta lie in it. Personally, I'm glad that I found an alternative scouting program for my son, one which doesn't exclude anyone from scouting (including girls and adults!). It's the Baden-Powell Service Association, and it's also "traditional scouting" with more of a focus on teaching outdoor skills (Scoutcraft) and community service. Look 'em up online: BPSA-US dot org.




log out