Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Commentary: Celebrate Urban Meyer, but don't forget Luke Fickell

periatt.1@osu.edu

Published: Monday, November 28, 2011

Updated: Tuesday, November 29, 2011 00:11

It has to be hard knowing you're going to be replaced before it happens — knowing the institution you've dedicated a large portion of your life to has decided you're not good enough.

It has to even harder pretending you're unaware.

That's what Ohio State coach Luke Fickell was facing Saturday after his team lost to Michigan for the first time since 2003.

Hoards of reporters crowded into a small room somewhere in the depths of Michigan Stadium to hear a lame-duck coach take the stand.

Fickell entered the room, brushed through reporters, and took a seat, staring directly ahead. He looked strained and defeated, but in typical Fickell fashion, he pressed on.

You see, if Fickell is one thing, it's a fighter. No matter what the circumstances, he perseveres and stays focused on his goal. It's what's defined him his whole life.

In high school, Fickell wasn't just a football star. He was a three-time state champion wrestler at Columbus DeSales. He went 106-0 in his final three years and was so dominant some of his opponents forfeited their matches against him in fear.

As a nose guard at OSU, Fickell started a school-record 50 consecutive games. He played the entire 1997 Rose Bowl with a torn pectoral muscle.

That's why when OSU was in the midst of its biggest scandal in program history, Fickell stepped forward and accepted the challenge. Why couldn't he do it? Why couldn't he fight through the adversity and succeed?

At first, people liked Fickell's no-nonsense mentality. They liked the toughness and structure he brought to a program that was in obvious need of some discipline.

But that was before the losses started.

First there was the close call against Toledo. Then there was the loss to Miami. Back-to-back losses to Michigan State and Nebraska moved the team to 3-3 and suddenly, Fickell's poor game management replaced his toughness as the topic of conversation.

There seemed to be a brief revival after a miracle-win against Wisconsin, but three consecutive losses to end the year extinguished all hope. The Fickell experiment would be a one-year endeavor.

Fickell knew all of this when facing the press after the Michigan game.

He knew Urban Meyer was going to be Ohio State's next head coach. He knew this was likely the last time he would face the media as the unquestioned head man at the university that's been such a central facet of his life since he was 18 years old.

There was no hesitation when the question portion of the press conference began. Reporters fired away on questions about Meyer replacing him and the uncertain future he had with the university. At first Fickell stood his ground. He diverted the questions back to the rivalry with the Wolverines.

But slowly, Fickell began to break.

I'll never forget when I first noticed it, but Fickell's eyes started to become glassy. I leaned to the person next to me and asked, "Is Fickell crying?"

He wasn't, but he was on the verge of tears. It looked like he could break down at any time.

Another question was asked regarding his future and Fickell had had enough. He slammed the table in frustration.

"It's about the Ohio State-Michigan game," Fickell said as his fist hit the table. "It's been about that since Sunday. It will be about that always."

The sequence of events is burned into my memory. It was the moment when Fickell, the man too tough to cry, almost broke down.

I think the fighter within him felt he lost. He finally met an opponent he couldn't beat. At a moment that has been filled with joy and BCS chatter, here he was discussing a 6-6 season that most consider a disappointment — a disappointment he led them to.

For the first time since he was hired as head coach, I think Fickell took a step back, reflected on the whole situation and didn't like what he saw. It cut him to the core not because he felt bad for himself, but because the state of the program was in such disarray. Columbus-born and bred with Scarlet and Gray coursing through his veins, Fickell felt like he failed the university he cared so much about.

It wasn't about money or job security. It was about selfless despair.

Maybe Fickell made some mistakes. Maybe he was put in an impossible situation. But Fickell took over the program at its lowest point, at a time when many wouldn't touch it. And he did it without hesitation.

Now, Meyer will take over that role. The former Florida coach was announced as OSU's new head coach Monday evening.

Fickell will coach the team in the bowl and will apparently be offered a position on Meyer's staff.

Most expect Fickell to accept the job, but make no mistake about it — this is Meyer's team now. He will be the face of the program and personally, I think he'll make OSU fans forget about the 6-6 season quickly.

But don't forget about the coach that led them there — the coach that cared so much it almost brought him to tears. The season may be forgettable, but the coach deserves to be remembered.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

12 comments

jimmybuckeye
Wed Nov 30 2011 13:52
I don't think keeping players out of trouble is meyer's strong point. Could be a crazy ride.
Fickell in a Pickle
Wed Nov 30 2011 12:49
I just hope Urban holds his players accountable. I assume Luke did the best he could do with some of the trouble making players, however he still put them right back in the game when they did something such as breaking the "code of conduct" rules. Luke stepped into a mess and I feel sorry for him but I do feel that things are still being swept under the rug and that is why some of the players continue to cause problems. We have more good guys than bad on the team and I just hope that Urban will set higher standards than Fickell or Tressel. When a coach looks the other direction when bad things happen they will continue to happen. One player was guilty of assault on campus, was put back in the game then accused of another assault and was back in the game for a short period. Another player guilty of disorderly conduct, back in the game.... All within 3 months while under Luke Fickell. Maybe if he had a zero tolerance this would not continue to happen. I wish the "O" in OSU stood for 0-zero tolerance when it comes to football but apparently it doesn't, apparently it's a number for how many points the trouble makers can score in a game! Urban, please have a back bone and stand up to the players and don't let them "rule the roost" if the players don't respect their team and follow the rules they shouldn't be on the team, what one player does and gets by with will affect the entire team! So Fickell allowed the players to play although they were out causing trouble, I'm not sure if that's good leadership, it does not matter what he "stepped into" it's how he reacted to what happens while he's at the helm. I only mentioned two players there are others causing trouble that have continued on the team under Fickell.
BobH
Wed Nov 30 2011 02:09
What a beautiful story about an incredible guy. He bravely accepted an impossible position and make a lot of mistakes, but he is young and will grow professionally. As for his heart and his loyalty, that's something that cannot be learned. Luke Fickell is a special person.
Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 15:41
Thanks, Coach Fickell, you did an exemplary job.

Welcome, Coach Meyer.

Kudos to Coach Tressel, you gave us an amazing record.

Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 15:30
As an alumnus I am sure that Woody,Earl Bruce, Jim Tressel and Luke Fickell will always be remembered with love by true buckeye fans. Yes and even John Cooper. Lets hope Meyer can earn the same love and respect as the aforementioned!
Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 14:59
I agree with Keb

Fickell should be head coach. I don't want Meyer's baggage here. We have more class than that. Do people honestly think that Meyer will waltz in here and serve up national championships on a silver platter? It's about doing it the right way. Under Meyer we're going to become another sleazy SEC team. Didn't this past year teach us anything?

Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 12:51
The testimony to Luke is good reporting. The bashing of Tressel by commentators is old news and bad taste. Jim Tressel is a terrific man and coach and has positively impacted over a thousand young men who were blessed to play under him. The first mistake was firing him. Suspension , even for a year, would have sufficed. But he should be welcomed and honored in Columbus as a great coach, with a great record who contributed money, time and sacricice of himself into the lives of many. Can't we simply turn the chapter, welcome Urban, and quit bashing ourselves ? I am sure if iyou ask Luke Fickle if Tressel was a good mentor, his answer will be absolutely ! He did not simpyl drop out of cloud. He was mentored and groomed, and he will surface again after more mentoring. I for one am not ashamed of Tressel or the program. I am ashamed of the university failed to handle it appropriately and those hid behind making JT the scapegoat. Welcome Urban, thanks for keeping Luke, and please use your grace to stop the bashing of Jim.
Keb
Tue Nov 29 2011 12:50
OSU showed little class in how the Board, Smith & Gee handled Luke Fickell. UMeyer will come on as Head Coach with the group of freshmen & shophmores that Fickell developed. Yes, he will look good & I hope that Luke stays on as Head Defense & Assnt. Head Coach. OSU will always be the greater of UM/OSU just because we are.
Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 12:41
Thank you for this article. I had no idea that he grew up in Columbus. What a true Ohio State man, a very fitting tribute indeed. He certainly did do what others would not have by coaching us this year, and hopefully the experience will help guide him to bigger and better things in the future.
Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 11:00
Poor Michigan still can't get no respect. They beat da Buckeyes and da Buckeyes bring out Urban Myer..poor ESPN they tried to PRETEND Mi was a great team for BARELY beating the Frosh QB! hahahahahaha I heard Tim Tebow will be on the sidelines with prayers hahahahaha. Welcome Urban but take care of Lou. He seems like such a GREAT guy!!!!
Anonymous
Tue Nov 29 2011 08:59
This is a well-written and beautiful tribute to a selfless man and a coach who exemplifies what Ohio State should strive to be. Coach Fickell did not NOT let the team or Buckeye Nation down; rather it was the immature and selfish players involved in the nearly year-long fiasco, Tressel, and Gene Smith. Coach Fickell epitomizes class and grace--aspects I hope the university administration, new coach and team can learn and acquire.
Bucks4Evah
Tue Nov 29 2011 06:32
It's not that Luke Fickell isn't "good enough:" Mr. Fickell is a relatively young man and therefore, his career is young. That he was chosen to lead Buckeye Football (a powerhouse) when the enterprise found itself in a crunch speaks volumes to Mr. Fickell's leadership skill, talent, and the spotlight that was already shining on him prior to the departure of Jim Tressell. In a few years, Luke Fickell will be a head coach among the ranks of the greatest. I very much hope that he remains with the Buckeye family.






log out