Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

Commentary: Ohio State football program becoming nothing more than litter box for ‘cats’

meisel.14@osu.edu

Published: Sunday, May 8, 2011

Updated: Saturday, June 16, 2012 01:06

gene smith

Andy Gottesman / Lantern photographer

Gene Smith

"This osu tattoo stuff is silly. Cats been getting hookups on tatts since back in '01."

Antonio Pittman and George Washington have more in common than their zero NFL touchdowns. Apparently, it's not just the United States' first president who can't tell a lie.

The former Ohio State running back leaked a bit of insider insight on his Twitter on Dec. 23, the day the NCAA announced suspensions of six Buckeye football players for selling memorabilia and receiving improper benefits.

Whether Pittman's claim is true, he seems to have foreshadowed one thing: Tattoo-gate was the tip of an iceberg large enough to make Jack and Rose quiver.

"Cats" have apparently "been getting hookups" on cars in Columbus for quite some time, too. But don't go telling the millions in Buckeye Nation that it's "silly." It's more startling than silly, more frightening than foolish, more jarring than juvenile.

The OSU football program is entering uncharted territory.

First came discounted tattoos.

Then came thousands of dollars worth of sold memorabilia.

Then came the revelation that coach Jim Tressel knew about the situation but opted to keep quiet.

Then came The Columbus Dispatch report that the OSU compliance department was looking into 40–50 transactions between two car dealerships and Buckeye athletes and their families.

Then came news that OSU football players were receiving free stamps at the post office.

Then came news that players were receiving Monopoly stickers from McDonald's without having to buy any Big Macs.

OK, I made up the last two. I'm just preparing.

Still, this is no longer just a black eye on the program. Both eyes are swollen shut, and there's no way of seeing what will happen next.

When the NCAA delivers its knockout punch, it likely will take OSU years to get back on its feet.

It's like tugging on the string that pulls down the ladder leading to the attic, only when you pull, years worth of storage falls in your face that you didn't think was there.

The untouched boxes sat and accumulated more and more dust over the years.

You didn't pay close enough attention. Now, ridding of that dust will take even longer than it did for it to pile up higher than Mount Everest.

It'll take a monsoon to rinse the dust off compliance director Doug Archie, athletic director Gene Smith, even university President E. Gordon Gee.

Thing is, NCAA compliance shouldn't be relegated to the attic in the first place.

For an athletic department sporting the nation's most varsity teams and one of the largest budgets, for a football program rooted in the sport's uppermost echelon of history and success, compliance must be the dining room, where nothing gets touched without permission. No one lays a finger on the expensive china without a university official overseeing the encounter.

It'll take much more than Tressel attending a five-day compliance seminar in early June to eradicate the problems running rampant throughout the program.

"We're very fortunate that we do not have a systemic problem in our program."

Smith said that the same day Pittman suggested otherwise.

Clearly, ignorance is no longer bliss at OSU. Ignorance placed Tressel in murky water. Now it's making Smith and the rest of the athletic department look naive.

OSU is working its way toward the NCAA's "death sentence," in which it deems an athletic department to have a "lack of institutional control." OSU avoided that charge in the NCAA's Notice of Allegations sent to Gee on April 21.

But that was before the car reports and before whatever inevitable infraction is unearthed next.

Archie's days appear to be numbered. Tressel's days appear to be numbered. Even Smith's clock could be ticking toward zero.

It'd be "silly" to rule anything out at this point. "Cats" haven't been caught red-handed like this before.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

36 comments

Anonymous
Fri Jun 24 2011 13:11
This Lantern article is a compilation of facts, semi-facts, unsubstantiated rumors, hints and a few outright untruths. The Lantern should insist on a higher standard of journalism. While it's true that a number of OSU athletes behaved in a very juvenile manner when they probably know better, and that their coach (to whom they looked for moral leadership) let them down in the most in a most grievous manner, I don't have any reason to believe the OSU athletic program is basically immoral, or that it is worse than almost ANY of the big-time, high pressure college programs. I'm angry and upset that these incidents s happened, but I hope, no matter what punishment is handed down, that lessons are learned and that I can continue to be a proud OSU Alumnus. John M
Patrice Brantley
Tue May 31 2011 21:01
This latest incident in sports is an extremely sad commentary on the city of Columbus, Thee Ohio State University, the Alumni, Coach Tressel, the Atletic Department, the players, students and all football fans across the country. It will do more harm than good to uncover years of dirt and to continue pointing the finger. All Tressel did is what any respected Coach would do, which is stand behind by his players, as long as possible. All the players did, is what all college students do, which is try to make a buck to support themselves. Is righting this wrong worth dismantling the whole football program, destroying careers, tarnishing players NFL chances, while tearing down the esteem of an entire community??? We may not recover from all the dominos that fall; this will hurt education, put a negative spotlight on other sports at the university, lessen revenue, stall new football recruits, and we have lost respect across the country; it has already, absolutely killed any chance of our bringing home a trophy, for years to come. Despite all that, I will still die a BUCKEYE!!!!!!!! O - H - I - O!!!!!!
Anonymous
Tue May 31 2011 16:16
Just wait until they start looking into the basketball program as well !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Anonymous
Mon May 30 2011 10:04
I missed this so called article when it first came out. Can not wait to revisit this witters life choices and career are more mature and defined in 20-30 years. I bet he is working at McDonald's (if he has a job at all) and complaining that life treated him badly. My 6th grader could do better than this! Kids......
Anonymous
Wed May 25 2011 11:47
The program went to the crossroads and struck a deal. Now it's time to pay you know who.

lyrics to "Tat gate", performed by the Dead Tressells. '11

TheLanternSucks
Fri May 13 2011 12:24
Another not-so-stellar article from The Lantern. Good going guys.
Anonymous
Wed May 11 2011 11:10
I will giv Zack props for expessing his opinion because afterall this is commentary. However, as a proud alum of tOSU I am disgusted by current students, alums, and faculty who are like lemmings reading storys which are no where near accuracte making judgements about the entire althletic program. Shame on all of you especially my fellow alums for not using the education our proud university provided you before making rash judgements about our school.
Danielle
Tue May 10 2011 10:31
Why are the students at Ohio State being so supportive of the football team and Jim Tressel when they are making this school look like crap? I don't understand how this opinion piece is an embarrassment to The Lantern. The only embarrassment I see here is our football team.
Disgusted Alumnus
Tue May 10 2011 10:16
The Lantern was an embarrassment in the 80's, and continues to be so today.
Anonymous
Tue May 10 2011 10:03
As a J-school and OSU alum, I'm not sure if I should be more embarassed by the school and football team, or this article. The tats and all that surround that mess, including they way Coach T has mis-handled it, are something about which all OSU fans and alums should be angry. It is way too early, however, to pass judgement on the car story, since I'm not aware of a single person that has gone on the record claiming that rules or laws were broken. So, let's not hang the program out to dry just yet. Allow the process to work, and then once all of the details and findings are in you can't go back to throwing stones. In the meantime, show a little journalistic integrity, and stick to the facts.
Anonymous
Tue May 10 2011 09:35
Note to brainless football players...stop tweeting you morons!
Special Report Update
Tue May 10 2011 01:53
WE INTERRUPT THIS THREAD FOR A SPECIAL REPORT UPDATE

The Associated Press is reporting that the NCAA Special Ops team will be releasing photos obtained during their daring nightime raid using helicopters to breach the walls of the Horseshoe to get to the office of O'Tressels Bin Lyin.

The photos show various pictures of Bin Lyin in Jeanette, PA as well as in front of various tattoo parlors, Jack Maxson Chevrolet and Autos Direct.

Other photos of the raid on O'Tressels Bin Lyin's office are considered too graphic in nature to be released at this time for fear that it will only cause distress to the Buckeye faithful in the small towns in Ohio, causing them to tug too roughly on their cow's udders at milking time.

PhillyBuck
Mon May 9 2011 23:16
So the new information here is what? A December 23rd tweet?

Or reporting the "new" information that OSU was looking into car purchases?

Just another recycled moral outrage piece by Zack the Hack Meisel. If there were even rumors of free postage stamps and Monopoly stickers, I am sure you would crank out another "end of OSU football" article.

In the past, talking heads have prematurely pronounced the program corrupt and Tressel as needing to leave - only to find out that accusations, insinuations and facts are the same thing. No big deal to ESPN or SI, they just pack up the circus and leave town. But idiots like Bill Livingston of the PD were left with egg to match the slobbering drool on his face. But that will never happen to a crack Junior Reporter like you, right?

Class of 1991
Mon May 9 2011 22:46
While I am willing to wait for all of the facts to come out before passing judgment on the football program as a whole, the facts established so far leave me deeply disappointed and angry at Jim Tressel, Doug Archie, and Gene Smith. I think it is time for all 3 men to show more honor than they have shown up to this point by resigning their positions. At the very least, Jim Tressel ought to resign, or, failing that, E. Gordon Gee ought to fire him.
embarrassed alumni
Mon May 9 2011 20:09
Shouldn't the responsibility of the Compliance Office and Tressel be to the % of football players who aren't on the take rather than spend time covering for the few who are wrecking our reputation? I say kick 'da bums' off the team - including Tress - or per above comment that every school does it - then recruit smarter players who know how not to get caught (just kidding). I'd rather have a mediocre program than a winning one that reeks of slime-ball antics and immature decision makers. Now we are the laughing stock of the conference, everyone piles on, and we've been ruined since now we really are Losers. GO BUCKS and if I could, I would lie myself and say I graduated elsewhere since this is SO awful it makes my skin crawl. Not sure I would go out on campus if I were one of those players mired in this mess.
anonymous
Mon May 9 2011 19:22
These idiots that write this drivel are even worse than the hypocrites at the Dispatch. Why do they want all this negativity on OSU? I think it's jealousy because some of these losers weren't good enough to be athletes so they have to try to destroy the football program and JT. The facts haven't even come out yet and these jackasses are just giddy with delight. For God's sake, it's your school which is the subject of your yellow "journalism"! You all should be ashamed!!!!!!!!!!
tOSU76
Mon May 9 2011 18:44
I am not aghast
Anonymous
Mon May 9 2011 17:21
What I find most amusing? The only OSU fans supporting Tressel and in denial are non-OSU grads... Alums are aghast by all this...
Anonymous
Mon May 9 2011 14:16
Sadly, I predict that very little will happen to the football program. The NCAA is as crooked as all the teams they "police". OSU brings in more money to the NCAA than any other team, and the Big 10(12) brings in more money than any other conference. They don't want to do too much damage to that as it would hurt NCAA football all around. That's the real story here.
Anonymous
Mon May 9 2011 13:25
I used to work at the Lantern, yet I'm not surprised to see terrible articles like this in the Lantern. Ohio State will NOT get a lack of institutional control, in part because the only violations 1) were done by players with outside parties, 2) were covered up by one man, the head coach, who failed to notify his superiors.

Tressel did wrong and should be punished, as should the players. However, it should be noted that Tressel's violations were reported BY THE UNIVERSITY during a review. They were the ones who submitted it to the NCAA.





log out