Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

The Big Blue demise

dilillo.2@osu.edu

Published: Tuesday, November 17, 2009

Updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2009 11:11

football

The Lantern


Almost a decade later, the first words Jim Tressel spoke as coach of Ohio State resonate as Michigan continues to set records for its ineptitude, and the Buckeyes look to again embarrass the Wolverines in Ann Arbor Saturday.

"I can assure you that you will be proud of your young people in the classroom, in the community, and most especially in 310 days in Ann Arbor, Mich., on the football field," Tressel said.

At the time, it might not have phased Michigan, its players, fans or even coach Lloyd Carr.

Michigan's downfall was slowly set in motion that day, and although its drastic demise has come more recently, Tressel has had as big a part as anyone. His dominance is one of many factors that have left a struggling Michigan program in its current predicament.

In 2006, the Buckeyes were decisively beating every opponent in their path. Troy Smith was on his way to a Heisman Trophy, and the Buckeyes were looking for their second national championship in five years.

Michigan, although not as highly ranked as OSU, was also playing extremely well. Both teams went undefeated through the regular and Big Ten seasons and met in "the game of the century." The No. 1 vs. No. 2 matchup in Columbus was believed to be one of the biggest regular season games the sport of college football had ever seen.

"The ‘06 game was unreal," senior captain Kurt Coleman said. "It was just an unreal game, the one versus two, coming off the field with the whole student section, the whole crowd rushing the field."

The game itself lived up to the hype, but the teams did not. OSU beat Michigan, 42-39, but neither team fared well in bowl games. Michigan, who many people thought should face OSU in a rematch, got throttled by USC in the Rose Bowl. OSU lost to Florida in the title game, 41-14.

Both teams were dismantled after most believed they were the two best in the country. This was the first instance in which the Big Ten would be put under fire for lack of competitiveness outside the Big Ten.

Many believed there would be better days ahead for the Wolverines, and OSU seemed to go into a rebuilding year in 2007.

Quarterback Chad Henne and running back Mike Hart had made an impact since their freshman seasons. As seniors, along with junior wideout Mario Manningham and eventual first overall pick Jake Long, the Wolverines were tabbed to be a major contender for the national championship.

Their campaign to bring Michigan its first national title since 1997 lasted all of four hours.

The Wolverines started the season with a "cupcake" game against then Division 1-AA Champion Appalachian State.

Unfortunately for Michigan, no one made ASU aware that it was to simply arrive at the Big House to collect its check and a loss.

The game was in doubt until late in the fourth quarter, but Michigan had gotten into field goal range with a chance to win by one point. A field goal from the ASU 20-yard line was blocked, and quite possibly the biggest upset in college football history had put an end to Michigan's title hopes.

"We'll still be talking about it a few decades from now," ESPN analyst Pat Forde said of the sport's most monumental upset. "Especially in the locker rooms of every huge underdog, where they'll say, ‘If Appalachian State can beat Michigan, why can't we shock the world, too?'"

The colossal letdown forced Michigan out of the Top 25 and had many Michigan faithful calling for Carr to be fired.

"I think it begins with being a prepared team, and that's my responsibility," Carr said of the upset. "I did not have the team prepared."

It was the beginning of the end for the longtime coach, as the following week Michigan was blown out at home, 39-7, by Oregon. It was his worst home loss.

Carr announced his retirement shortly after losing to OSU at home in November, his sixth defeat in seven years against the Buckeyes. A win against defending National Champion Florida in the Capital One Bowl was Michigan's last shining moment.

While Carr's time at Michigan was coming to a dismal end, LSU was on the verge of becoming the first school to win two BCS National Championships.

LSU's coach Les Miles seemed to be the most suited and desired candidate by the university and fans, alike. Playing for Michigan under Bo Schembechler and being an assistant coach there twice made Miles the most coveted guy for the position. But he decided to stay at LSU, and Michigan scrambled to find a suitable replacement for Carr.

Insert Rich Rodriguez, a guy who didn't grow up in Michigan or play there. His offensive philosophy, the spread offense, was a 180-degree turn from the more conventional, Big Ten style of offense Michigan had run for decades.

It was a move that had some scratching their heads, and after almost two seasons, most wonder if this drastic coaching decision is already a failed experiment.

At the time, a fan base starved for success embraced the move, hoping to go forward with much enthusiasm for the supposed "revival" of the winningest program in college football history.

Fans saw immediate results from the hire. The nation's No. 1 recruit, quarterback Terrelle Pryor, stated a newfound interest in the Wolverines. Their new spread offense suited Pryor's skill set perfectly, and he was seriously considering West Virginia before Rodriguez left.

Rodriguez's initial transition was anything but smooth. He left West Virginia, his alma mater, under compromised circumstances after recently signing a contract extension. His roster was filled with another coach's players, who weren't used to Rodriguez's way and didn't suit his style of coaching.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

20 comments

Mitch Igan
Fri Nov 20 2009 00:50
How 'bout those Apps!
juninho
Wed Nov 18 2009 14:15
@ ALEX:

Who was the last non-SEC school to beat Florida?: Michigan. Lloyd's last game in the Cap One Bowl in 1/1/2008... That was Florida's only bowl loss between its two national championship seasons... Seems like sooooooo long ago for UM fans!!! Save us from the nightmare called RichRod!

A
Wed Nov 18 2009 12:57
Very well written, this kid knows his stuff. I still get excited about the rivalry but it is nothing like it used to be. Michigan is such a horrible team, I almost want them to get better so it can be more fun. Oh well. GO BUCKS!
ALEX
Wed Nov 18 2009 12:34
Has anyone else notice that playing Michigan now feels more and more like playing Bowling Green? Don't get me wrong, I love to see Michigan lose, but I have lost that enigmatic impulse to go riot and light dumpsters on fire anymore after Ohio State whips Michigan's butt. I would like to propose a vote... Who would you rather Ohio State play at the end of the season. Michigan or Florida? I urn for the day when Ohio State can play those Gators. Where God meant football to be played in the good old gloomy and shivering cold Columbus, Ohio. You know the football HEART of it all! GO BUCKS!!!
M
Wed Nov 18 2009 09:13
Great article
Allen C
Wed Nov 18 2009 09:09
First sentence of this article: "Almost a decade later, the first words Jim Tressel spoke as coach of Ohio State resonate as Michigan continues to set records for its, and the Buckeyes look to again embarrass the Wolverines in Ann Arbor Saturday."

Question: Michigan continues to set records for its WHAT ???????

Greg OSU'82
Wed Nov 18 2009 07:40
Let's hope michigan does not hire John Cooper, because he knew how to make them win!!!!
Mark
Wed Nov 18 2009 06:06
Rich Rodriguez is the best thing that happened to Meatchicken Football. Please keep him as coach for ever.
BuckeyeCub
Wed Nov 18 2009 00:41
I think Michigan should give Rich Rodriguez one more year regardless of what happens on Saturday. I think year 3 will be his year, when he finally has his guys in there. If not, then fire him.
cindy s
Tue Nov 17 2009 23:02
I hope the Buckeyes don't go into this game too overconfident. Michigan may have not had a good season , but that strong rivalry is still present.
GO BUCKS! BEAT MEECHEGAN!!!!!! You wil be heaaring us cheer you on, all the way from New Jersey.
missinglloyd...
Tue Nov 17 2009 23:01
I liked Lloyd Carr. As a michigan native, Carr represented everything a michigan man is, and everything coach should be. But he was a man of a different time. He was loyal. He was no Steve Spurrier or Nick Saban. He was one of the best coaches that UofM ever had, and should still be coaching there. (maybe then they'd be at 35 straight bowl games). But who knows. Due to the imbecility of Wolverines fans, he's gone. Maybe they could get him to come back out of retirement, if they asked nice enough, and acted sorry enough. And they should at least try. Maybe then Michigan football will begin to return to it's former glory, otherwise it may all be in the past.
Kyle
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:55
Get rid of Rich Rod, hire a good old fashioned Michigan Man, as the saying goes, and Michigan football will be able to start to get back on it's feet, maybe even begin to punch back. No one likes beating up on a little kid, and as a Buckeye fan, that's what it's felt like the past two years. What started with Bo is, we can only hope temporarily, dead. I'm sure Bo and even Woody are rolling in their graves right now. UofM used to be such a proud school, and now they have nothing to be proud of. All UofM needs is a man with Michigan character, and they'll be competitive again. They have the tools, RR is just a horrendous coach. Here's to ND hiring him (we can only pray and cross our fingers).
Loyd
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:49
Living and working in Ann Arbor, I have never seen a time when morale was so low. There is no excitement here for the BIG GAME -- unbelievable.
SalineHornet
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:43
Living and working in Ann Arbor, I have never seen a time when morale was so low. There is no excitement here for the BIG GAME -- unbelievable.
Your name
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:32
Did you have to bring up Cooper? Now I am sick.

Michigan needs to get rid of Rich Rod. Maybe Notre Dame will hire him to follow Charlie. That would make my day.

Doug
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:15
Clark,

Sadly, we learned our lesson about Holbrook only AFTER she began nailing the coffin of all that was good about OSU football. Hineygate is dead, and the big tailgating atmosphere of Lane Avenue is breathing its final breaths, thanks largely to the work done by the Holbrook Prohibition Squad. To paraphrase Crosby, Stills and Nash: "It's getting to the point, where it's just no fun anymore."

Bluto
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:11
Michigan still sucks www.osuh1.com
Doug
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:11
Kudos to the Lantern for a well researched and balanced article. As a Buckeye, I actually want Michigan to go back to its winning ways. A strong Michigan Wolverine team is good for both The Rivalry, and the national reputation of the Big Ten. In short, I think Ohio State only benefits from Michigan as a national contender. Of course, I also want to beat them into the dirt every November. But after that's over, I want both of us going into BCS bowls and giving SEC teams hell.
Clark
Tue Nov 17 2009 22:07
I'm a Buckeye alumni and ardent fan... yet even I can lament what has happened to the Michigan football program over the few seasons. To say the Ohio State-Michigan rivalry has no equal in college football, is becoming an "endangered statement." Historically, Michigan has been one of the most respected college football programs in the country. No more it appears. If only to inject some life into the Buckeye-Wolverine game, I sincerely hope the AD discharges RR after Saturday's win to the Scarlet & Gray! Lesson learned! Remember OSU's abysmal president, Karen Holbrook? Another "misfit" who had no Midwest or Big Ten ties. OSU had the courage and guts to get rid of her. Hopefully Michigan will have the same backbone after Saturday.
juninho
Tue Nov 17 2009 21:27
As a Michigan fan, It's tough to read this article... but it is well researched and sadly speaks the truth... a lot of Lloyd haters expected a "revival" of the program under RR but all we've gotten is 2 losing seasons... Let's hope RR doesn't last 13 seasons like Cooper did at Ohio State!






log out